Last week the Daily Mail published an undercover investigation into certain aspects of IVF practice in the UK (reported elsewhere in BioNews this week). Whilst this has highlighted some issues, unfortunately the meaning of published statistics has been misinterpreted and certain aspects of the investigation have been given far more weight than is just. Rather than serving the public good, this has the potential to leave vulnerable patients scared and confused.
The IVF sector is the mostly highly regulated of all areas of medicine in the UK, nonetheless there may well be pockets of bad practice and clearly there is room for improvement in some areas. This is the case in any branch of medicine and the fertility sector is certainly no worse than any other. Information provided to patients must enable them to discern for themselves whether an individual clinic is offering appropriate advice and treatment. My concern is that this report muddies the waters, making it difficult for patients to make an informed choice about their care.
The fertility sector has a higher proportion of private practice because of a lack of NHSfunding and the associated postcode lottery. I have been campaigning hard for this to change and, on behalf of the British Fertility Society (BFS), Fertility Network UK and Fertility Fairness am chairing the IVF Pricing Committee for NHS England. The lack of NHS funding has created a unique scenario where all treatments must be itemised and charged for (either to CCGswhen there is NHS funding or directly to patients when there is not).
So we are dealing with the symptoms of a much more serious problem, namely that the majority of patients dealing with infertility are unable to access sufficient NHS funded treatments to become pregnant.
The Daily Mail highlighted a few areas where they perceived concern. One of these is egg sharing, whereby women donate some of their eggs during the course of their own IVF treatment cycle in order to be able to help fund that treatment. Donating or sharing eggs for IVF is a completely legitimate practice, and was already happening in the late 1990s. In other countries both egg and sperm donors would be paid for their donation, but here it was decided that it was wrong to incentivise in that way and risk exploiting people who are in poverty. We are only allowed to compensate patients for reasonable expenses, and couples must be very clear about the issues surrounding such treatment.
Egg sharing has been shown to work well for the vast majority of patients and is, of course, dependent upon very careful and thorough counselling about the implications. The Daily Mails investigation has, however, highlighted some questionable practices that may have affected some patients who participated in egg sharing in return for free or discounted treatment. The UK regulator, the HFEA (Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority), is rightly taking this seriously. But this, from my viewpoint in active clinical practice, and contrary to the highly critical view expressed by Professor Winston, is not something that is universal in the field.
All couples facing infertility deal with ethical and emotionally challenging decisions around their course of action and their genetic association with their children: anything from adoption to egg-sharing, sperm donation or mitochondrial donation requires complex moral and ethical considerations. There is a myriad of underlying causes including lack of fertility education in schools, lack of NHS funding for IVF that create a financial incentive for patients who struggle to pay for IVF privately and lack of appropriate healthcare advice during reproductive years as to lifestyle factors that can affect gamete quality and fertility.
A further investigation into reporting of OHSS (Ovarian HyperStimulation Syndrome) is somewhat misleading. I do not believe there is a major problem with clinics under-reporting serious cases of OHSS. The numbers reported by NHS hospitals include admissions to hospital after egg collection, the majority of which are for relatively mild symptoms that settle down on their own within a few days these are very different from full-blown OHSS, which can indeed be very serious. My organisation, the British Fertility Society (BFS), along with the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists (RCOG), have taken the lead in developing guidelines on how to prevent and treat OHSS. These guidelines are widely followed across the world.
We at the BFS accept absolutely that there are areas of poor practice in the fertility sector. We do not seek to dismiss valid concerns; exploitation or endangerment of patients is totally unacceptable. We trust that the HFEA will deal with any cases it uncovers and we will encourage our professional community to cooperate in the investigations. Meanwhile, we will continue to argue in support of NHS funding for fertility treatment, the lack of which we believe remains a factor driving potentially contentious practice.
The BFS has written numerous Policy & Practice Papers and guidelines to better inform the profession, alongside our training courses, study weeks and academic symposia. These are attended by those of us in active practice who seek to update our knowledge and ensure that we are providing evidence-based treatments. We are disappointed with the criticism levied at us by Professor Winston in his Daily Mail opinion piece on the investigation we are a professional body that he himself once chaired. Given this, we would like to send an open invitation to Professor Winston to attend our meetings and hear the latest data and innovations.
The UK leads the way with innovation in IVF and other infertility treatments and the BFS works with our community to share good practice. We also work with the regulators and policy makers to ensure that ethically challenging issues are embraced with tight but permissive regulation. In theory, the UK is one of the best places in the world scientifically and medically to be a person dealing with infertility, but without NHS funding for treatment this point is moot.
NICE (National Institute for Health and Care Excellence) recommends that the NHS offers three full cycles of IVF treatment. But the most recent statistics from Fertility Fairness showed that only 16 percent of CCGswere providing three cycles, with 60 percent offering only one, and 22 percent offering two. Its true that we are experiencing a period of austerity politics and that we have an ageing population, both of which are challenging our NHS. There are also social factors particularly the increase in numbers of people delaying parenthood until later in life that are compounding these issues. But it doesnt have to be this way.
Not treating infertility properly can actually cost the NHS a lot of money: infertility is the second most common reason that a woman visits her GP (the first being pregnancy), and people who are dealing with infertility commonly suffer stress, anxiety, and depression, which can cause lifelong health issues that require treatment. Yet there appears to be some short-sightedness on the part of decision makers in some CCGs - it really isnt as simple as dividing up the pot of money within the CCG, as there is a net cost of not treating infertility. This cost could be saved if the NICE guidelines were followed.
See the original post here:
Daily Mail misses the mark on fertility - BioNews
- Exposing the Secret Cost of IVF: Heartbreak and a Second Mortgage - Yahoo Finance - December 9th, 2019
- Utahs fertility rate falls below replacement level for the first time but theres more to the story - Deseret News - December 9th, 2019
- Coronation Streets Alan Halsall and Tisha Merry set tongues wagging after shes spotted wearing a fertility b - The Sun - December 9th, 2019
- More families join lawsuit against Grand Junction doctor accused of using his sperm to inseminate patients - The Denver Post - December 9th, 2019
- China gene-edited baby experiment 'may have created unintended mutations' - The Guardian - December 9th, 2019
- Brexit Will Bring a Baby Boom, Boris Johnson Promises - The New York Times - December 9th, 2019
- CM Murad Ali Shah vows to bring down fertility rate from 3.6pc to 2.8pc by 2025 - The News International - December 9th, 2019
- The US fertility rate dropped dropped for the fourth year in a row - INSIDER - December 3rd, 2019
- Artificial Insemination Market Size, Share & Trends Analysis Report 2019-2026: Focus on End Use (Home, Fertility Clinics & Other Facilities),... - December 3rd, 2019
- Eva Marcille, The Basketball Wives And Everyone Else On Reality TV Need To Stop Weaponizing Fertility - MadameNoire - December 3rd, 2019
- Martha's Vineyard News | New Regulations Push Herring Trawlers Further Offshore - The Vineyard Gazette - Martha's Vineyard News - December 3rd, 2019
- Governors plan will test 90% of populations water supply for forever chemicals - The Columbus Dispatch - December 3rd, 2019
- Does fertility treatment still need to be a medical secret? - BioNews - December 2nd, 2019
- Seven Startups to Watch - Twin Cities Business Magazine - December 2nd, 2019
- Milk yields and the relationship it has with rumen function - Farming Life - December 2nd, 2019
- Commentary: Miscarriages affect 1 in 6 pregnancies - but is rarely caused by anything the mother did - CNA - December 1st, 2019
- Diabetes may cause infertility in men; here are some precautionary measures - Business Standard - December 1st, 2019
- After the One-Child Policy - Slate - December 1st, 2019
- Coastal fog linked to high levels of mercury found in mountain lions, study finds - UC Santa Cruz - December 1st, 2019
- Challenges to reproductive performance in pigs - Agriland - December 1st, 2019
- Where are all the babies? - Herald Palladium - December 1st, 2019
- U.S. Fertility Rate Falls for Fourth Consecutive Year in 2018, Reaching Record Low - National Review - November 29th, 2019
- New Zealand launches world's first HIV positive sperm bank - The Guardian - November 29th, 2019
- When You're A Woman Of Colour, Infertility Comes With Extra Stigma - HuffPost UK - November 29th, 2019
- U.S. Life Expectancy Drops for Third Consecutive Year Largely Due to Alcoholism, Drugs and Suicide - National Review - November 29th, 2019
- Global Male Infertility Market 2019 by Manufacturers, Regions, Type and Application, Forecast to 2025 - Global Market News 24 - November 29th, 2019
- Worlds first HIV positive sperm bank opens in New Zealand to dispel stigma - Republic World - Republic World - November 29th, 2019
- Marijuana use and its impacts on fertility - AZFamily - November 19th, 2019
- Fertility startup Mojo wants to take the trial and error out of IVF - TechCrunch - November 19th, 2019
- Anna Louie Sussman: Is this the end of babies? - Salt Lake Tribune - November 19th, 2019
- First of kind SA event aims to help couples break the infertility barrier | Saturday Star - IOL - November 19th, 2019
- Turkey still has a young but aging population - Hurriyet Daily News - November 19th, 2019
- 10 superfoods to improve fertility levels - The Indian Express - November 19th, 2019
- Anorexia and infertility: can you have children after an eating disorder? - cosmopolitan.com - November 19th, 2019
- Living with cancer: 'My treatment brought on the menopause at 15 and left me infertile' - inews - November 19th, 2019
- Fertilization Discovery Reveals New Role for the Egg - University of Virginia - November 19th, 2019
- News - mip.fertility.com - November 9th, 2019
- Fertility News | Greenwich Fertility - October 25th, 2019
- IN THE NEWS | Read Recent News Stories about New Hope - September 13th, 2019
- Fertility News | Latest Fertility Treatment | Health24 - September 9th, 2019
- US fertility rate is below level needed to replace ... - September 9th, 2019
- Fertility MOT: What is it and do I need one? - The Independent - July 31st, 2017
- Not ready for baby? Check fertility anyway - The Straits Times - July 31st, 2017
- Investigating myths of what helps and hurts male fertility - WBIR-TV - July 31st, 2017
- For Better, For Worse: 10 Suggestions For Coping With Fertility Struggles And Stress During Marriage - HuffPost - July 31st, 2017
- Families, fertility and feminism: landmarks in women's rights - The Guardian - July 31st, 2017
- Fertility charity condemns plans that could end NHS funded IVF treatment in Hertfordshire - Hertfordshire Mercury - July 31st, 2017
- VAT-free fertility treatment extended to all those eligible throughout the EU - The Copenhagen Post - Danish news in english - June 30th, 2017
- Heart disease: a price humans pay for fertility? - Health24 - June 29th, 2017
- Living on a busy road may affect fertility - The Times (subscription) - June 27th, 2017
- Vegetable protein could prolong female fertility - iNews - June 27th, 2017
- Campaign nudges couples to go for fertility checks early - The Straits Times - June 27th, 2017
- Poor soil fertility behind deaths of plants in Navi Mumbai - The Hindu - June 27th, 2017
- Most fertility clinics not on ICMR radar - The Hindu - June 25th, 2017
- Heart Disease: A Price Humans Pay for Fertility? | Health ... - Bloomington Pantagraph - June 25th, 2017
- Men, we need to talk about sperm - The Guardian - June 23rd, 2017
- In vitro fertilisation at Medicover Fertility in India - Treatment Abroad - June 23rd, 2017
- Offspring in Dutch fertility clinic row can access donor records - Yahoo Singapore News - June 20th, 2017
- Fertility doctor offering to blend eggs from two women to make 'three-parent' babies - National Post - June 18th, 2017
- Increase Fertility | News, Forum & Solutions | myeIVF - June 18th, 2017
- Couple faced with fertility issues wants to see IVF funding in Alberta - Globalnews.ca - June 18th, 2017
- Foundation to Offer Fertility Grant to Nigerians - THISDAY Newspapers - June 16th, 2017
- Free event to help couples with fertility problems explore different routes to parenthood - Cambridge News - June 12th, 2017
- Rise in Hong Kong women taking extra DNA test during fertility treatment - South China Morning Post - June 10th, 2017
- The Truth About Fertility After 35 - Information Nigeria - June 10th, 2017
- Struggling with fertility? Gene testing vital for herd improvement - FG Insight - June 7th, 2017
- Male fertility hits an all-time low, but Rooibos could help say experts - South Coast Herald - June 6th, 2017
- Homeopathic treatment for fertility issues - TheChronicleHerald.ca - June 6th, 2017
- High fertility rate impacts education, health investments - Loop PNG - June 4th, 2017
- New 'fertility calculator' for women with breast cancer - Ten Eyewitness News - June 4th, 2017
- Ovulation and fertility - Farmer's Weekly - June 4th, 2017
- DNA of fertility clinic doctor can be tested - Sky News - June 2nd, 2017
- Painter's fertility prayers answered - Gippsland Times - May 31st, 2017
- OncBioMune Receives Approval for Male Fertility Product in Mexico - Markets Insider - May 31st, 2017
- The State of Fertility in Israel - Jewish Link of New Jersey - May 26th, 2017
- Boost your fertility naturally - The Standard - May 17th, 2017
- Employers should consider coverage for fertility treatment - Hamilton Spectator - May 12th, 2017
- Some unconventional family reproductive arrangements can 'simulate' incest, experts warn - National Post - May 12th, 2017
- CCG rationing continues as five completely scrap free fertility treatment - Pulse - May 9th, 2017
- Fertility Centers of Illinois Celebrates Nurses Week - EconoTimes - May 9th, 2017