A Republican senator, Mitt Romney, joined Democrats this month in supporting an idea: a monthly child allowance for parents. One reason, he said, was to increase the number of births.
Family policies have lots of goals, including decreasing child poverty, helping parents manage work and family, and improving childrens health and education. But would a child allowance increase fertility?
Research from around the world suggests that, like other fertility policies, payments to parents do slightly increase the number of babies people have in the near term. But no move has made a major long-term difference, and payments are not as effective as other policies, particularly subsidized child care.
Sign up for The Morning newsletter from the New York Times
The proposed payments also raise another question: whether encouraging people to have more children should be a policy goal in the first place.
Much better, more effective and better for human rights, is to create conditions that allow people to control their fertility, and have children if they want to, said Philip Cohen, a sociologist studying demographics at the University of Maryland.
Government benefits to encourage women to have children, known as pronatalist policies, are common in other rich countries, where the birthrate began falling well before it did in the United States, around 2008. Governments worry about declining fertility for many reasons, including that the next generation finances the safety net and provides the caregivers, inventors and public servants of the future.
The birthrate in the United States fell in part because of large decreases in births among two groups: teenage and Hispanic women. The Great Recession also contributed to the fertility decline births have sunk below replacement level since then, and there are indications that the pandemic may decrease fertility further. American women are also waiting longer to have babies.
There are many reasons. Would-be parents face challenges like the rising cost of child care, record student debt, a lack of family-friendly policies, workplace discrimination against mothers, and concerns about climate change and political unrest. At the same time, women have more options for their lives than ever before and more control over their reproduction. As countries become wealthier, and as women have more opportunities, fertility rates decline, data shows.
Story continues
The problem, social scientists say, is if would-be parents are not having babies they want because society has made it too hard, too expensive and too solitary a job. This is called unmet fertility, and financial concerns are a driving factor.
The framework I prefer is about reproductive autonomy, said Sarah Cowan, a sociologist studying fertility at New York University. The concern, she said, is if people who want children cannot have them because they cannot afford to: Thats an inequality that I cant abide.
This is where family policies can help, including child allowances. Research from other countries shows that direct payments lead to a slight increase in birthrates at least at first. In Spain, for instance, a child allowance led to a 3% increase in birthrates; when it was canceled, birthrates dropped 6%. The benefit seems to encourage women to have children earlier, but not necessarily to have more of them so even if it increases fertility in a given year, it doesnt have large effects over a generation.
In addition to the international evidence, there is data on the effect of direct payments on parents in the United States. Alaskans get a payment each year, based on oil revenues. Because it varies annually and increases with the number of children, researchers have been able to examine its impact on fertility. Payments increased fertility, their studies have shown. A study that covered the years 1984 to 2010 found the increase was bigger for some groups: Alaskan Natives; those without college degrees; and unmarried women.
These groups had economic barriers to enacting their fertility goals, and this cash somehow was enough, said Kiara Douds, a doctoral candidate in sociology at New York University who wrote the study with Cowan.
The Alaska data, like that of Europe, suggests that women had babies earlier, but most didnt necessarily end up having more. The biggest increase in fertility was among people 25 to 34 and for first births, but there was little change in third births.
Some countries have focused their policies on encouraging larger families, largely as a way to fend off immigration, a strategy common among right-wing populists. Hungary has given women who have at least four children a lifelong exemption from personal income tax; provided free fertility treatments; and subsidized cars with seven or more seats for families of three or more children, among other measures.
President Joe Biden has proposed a monthly child allowance for a year, to help get families through the pandemic, while Romneys plan would be permanent. Experts say it would be more durable and effective to pursue a full package of policies that support families.
Cash now might help cushion the immediate decline associated with this crisis, but I think health care, child care, housing and job support would all matter more, Cohen said.
Public child care is the only policy that has been shown to increase fertility in a lasting way, research shows, especially if its quality is high, and if its available for children of all ages and covers a range of work hours. Parental leave helps if its paid, and if its not too long (otherwise it can end up making it harder for parents to keep up at work). So can policies that decrease obstacles to having babies: things like subsidizing fertility treatments, education and housing.
Long work hours, especially in countries where men work 45 hours or more a week on average, are associated with decreases in fertility. So are work cultures that make it difficult to work part time, or to increase or decrease hours as family responsibilities change.
France, which has among the higher birthrates in Europe, has policies focused on improving the well-being of children and parents. The policies include family allowances; tax breaks for families; housing assistance; public child care; and 35-hour workweeks.
Japan has put in place many family policies to try to reverse sharp population declines. But they have been offset by other factors, including long, rigid work hours and strict gender roles.
Single policy measures are unlikely to increase fertility, especially when they are modeled on the outdated assumptions about families and gender roles, wrote researchers from the Wittgenstein Centre, a research group in Vienna that studies population dynamics, in a paper for the United Nations Population Fund.
Policies should respond to diverse needs of the population and not to the ideological beliefs of the policymakers, they wrote.
In the U.S., Democrats have generally been more supportive than Republicans of government-supported family policies, seeing them as ways to decrease child poverty, recognize the value of parents unpaid labor and help women continue to work after becoming mothers.
Recently, some Republicans have argued that the party should do more to support families, but they have long tended to disagree on how much or whether mothers should be working. A child allowance appeals to them because it subsidizes families regardless of whether mothers work and gives parents freedom in how to spend it.
The U.S. is a challenging place to raise children, as the pandemic has made painfully clear. Family policies are unlikely to do much in the way of significantly increasing fertility. But they could provide parents with relief, and make for a more family-friendly society.
This article originally appeared in The New York Times.
2021 The New York Times Company
See the article here:
Would Americans Have More Babies if the Government Paid Them? - Yahoo News
- FTC Settlement With Fertility-Tracking App May Have Costly Ramifications for Companies Who Use Third-Party Data Analytics Software - JD Supra - February 20th, 2021
- Stem cells can give new life to ovaries and potentially restore fertility - Massive Science - February 17th, 2021
- Fertility Among Immigrants and Native-Born Americans - Immigration Blog - February 17th, 2021
- Boost your fertility with oysters, seaweed and other foods - Lowvelder - February 17th, 2021
- Shropshire professor appointed to world-leading fertility organisation - shropshirestar.com - February 17th, 2021
- Rape trial hears Indigenous tour guide offered to help alleged victims with fertility, trauma - ABC News - February 17th, 2021
- Do you really need IVF? This free online tool can help you weigh up your options - News24 - February 17th, 2021
- How A Once-In-A-Lifetime Pandemic Created Fertile Ground For Workplace And Organizational Transformation - Forbes - February 16th, 2021
- Fertility play Virtus Health continues its strong form with profits doubling - Stockhead - February 16th, 2021
- Trumps Popularity Among Republicans Is on the Rise - New York Magazine - February 16th, 2021
- The fertility hormone test you can take at home | Modern ... - February 14th, 2021
- Men's Clinic in Johannesburg | Men's Clinic, Penis ... - February 14th, 2021
- The best 10 Gynaecology & Obstetrics in Johannesburg 2021 - February 14th, 2021
- Governor Cuomo Announces New Actions to Expand Access to Fertility Coverage for Same Sex Couples as Part of 2021 Women's Agenda - ny.gov - February 14th, 2021
- Utah bill would help Medicaid patients diagnosed with cancer preserve ability to have children - Salt Lake Tribune - February 14th, 2021
- Column: Everyone has to pay when America gets too old - Yakima Herald-Republic - February 14th, 2021
- Tips to Boost Fertility in Women With PCOS/PCOD - India.com - February 14th, 2021
- Sexual and Reproductive Health Awareness Day: Protect your fertility by preventing STIs - Times Now - February 14th, 2021
- Surprising things that affect female fertility | Features | wfmz.com - 69News WFMZ-TV - February 14th, 2021
- 'Practicing Catholic' show focuses on practicing fertility awareness - TheCatholicSpirit.com : TheCatholicSpirit.com - The Catholic Spirit - February 14th, 2021
- Conspiracy theories of QAnon find fertile ground in an unexpected place the yoga world - Minneapolis Star Tribune - February 14th, 2021
- How Food Choices Affect Fertility & What You Should Actually Be Eating - BabyGaga - February 14th, 2021
- Thailand sees alarming drop in total fertility rate - The Star Online - February 14th, 2021
- Fertility drugs for women Market 2021-2028 Is Booming Worldwide with Comprehensive Study Explores Huge Revenue Scope in Future KSU | The Sentinel... - February 14th, 2021
- Global Fertility Enhancing Treatment Market 2020 Industry Analysis Report, Regional Outlook, Application Development Potential, Competitive Share... - February 14th, 2021
- Health Department Reports Record Low Fertility Rate in Thailand - Chiang Rai Times - February 14th, 2021
- The Femtech Market Is Booming. Here Are Some of the Risks and Rewards - The Story Exchange - January 31st, 2021
- Donor Egg IVF Services Market Research Report by Type, by End-user - Global Forecast to 2025 - Cumulative Impact of COVID-19 - GlobeNewswire - January 31st, 2021
- Fertile Ground May Be Virtual This Year, but It's Still Vibrant - Willamette Week - January 31st, 2021
- Legal marijuana: why it could be fertile ground for the next mega-brand - The Drum - January 31st, 2021
- Can the COVID vaccine affect fertility? The short answer is no - KTVI Fox 2 St. Louis - January 20th, 2021
- Philips and Merck partner to develop personalised fertility treatment - Mobihealth News - January 20th, 2021
- Ovation Fertility Fort Worth Announced as Ovation's Newest Lab Location - GlobeNewswire - January 20th, 2021
- RMA of Connecticut Creates Initiative to Educate Prospective Fertility Patients on the Importance of Using SART Data to Choose the Best Fertility... - January 20th, 2021
- The future of fertility | WIRED UK - Wired.co.uk - January 20th, 2021
- Some women are scared about the Covid vaccine harming their fertility should they be? - Telegraph.co.uk - January 20th, 2021
- Global Fertility Test Market Analysis of Key Players, End User, Demand and Consumption By 2026 - KSU | The Sentinel Newspaper - January 20th, 2021
- In-Vitro Fertilization Services Market To Witness Relatively Significant Growth During Forecast to 2026 - KSU | The Sentinel Newspaper - January 20th, 2021
- Korea's KAHF-Designated Hospitals Taking the Lead in Protecting Rights and Interest of International Patients and Offering Quality Medical Services -... - January 20th, 2021
- Disparities in Fertility Treatments, Another Layer of Racism - BELatina - January 20th, 2021
- We're Watching These Trends At Jinxin Fertility Group (HKG:1951) - Simply Wall St - January 20th, 2021
- Revealed: the dairy secret of high fertility and high yield - Wales Farmer - January 20th, 2021
- FTC Reaches Settlement With Flo Health Over Fertility-Tracking App - The Wall Street Journal - January 15th, 2021
- Developer of Popular Women's Fertility-Tracking App Settles FTC Allegations that It Misled Consumers About the Disclosure of their Health Data, FTC... - January 15th, 2021
- Fellow receives clinical validation for mail-in, male fertility test in recently published journal article, ushering in a new era for men, clinicians... - January 15th, 2021
- How every state's population compares to countries around the world - Roanoke Times - January 15th, 2021
- Medical expert seeks to debunk myths that Covid-19 vaccines affect fertility - Belfast Telegraph - January 15th, 2021
- Impact of Covid-19 on Fertility Medicines Market Influencing the Industry Development and Forecast |Allergan Plc, Ferring BV, Merck KGaA, Novartis AG,... - January 15th, 2021
- Fertile-Beltrami community rallies around family of mother and daughter killed in Grand Forks downtown crash - INFORUM - January 15th, 2021
- The best prenatal vitamins for women and how to take them to boost your fertility - Insider - INSIDER - January 15th, 2021
- Your guide to a fertility checkup - The Indian Express - January 15th, 2021
- Canadian millions help fast track expansion of Bourn Hall fertility capacity - Business Weekly - January 15th, 2021
- Apollo Fertility expands its presence with a State-of-the-art Centre - PR Newswire India - January 5th, 2021
- Shady Grove Fertility (SGF) Physicians Kick Off the New Year with Free Virtual Events to Educate Information Seekers about Options to Overcome... - January 5th, 2021
- Psychological distress and postponed fertility care during the COVID-19 pandemic - DocWire News - January 5th, 2021
- Planning to start a family this year, here are 5 fertility tips - Times of India - January 5th, 2021
- Fertility Treatment and IVF in Czech Republic During the Coronavirus Pandemic - Prague Morning - January 5th, 2021
- Global Soil Fertility Testing Market 2020 by Company, Regions, Type and Application, Forecast to 2025 - Farming Sector - January 5th, 2021
- A second creation storya human created first - Downtown - Church of the Resurrection - January 5th, 2021
- Argentine black and white tegus are nonnative to Florida, but they're here - and not welcome! - positivelyosceola.com - January 4th, 2021
- The Impact of COVID-19 on the Fertility Sector - BioNews - December 21st, 2020
- No evidence to suggest that COVID-19 impacts fertility: Gynaecologist - United News of India - December 21st, 2020
- Option To Freeze Ovarian Tissue Gives Young Cancer Patients - On the Pulse - December 21st, 2020
- Baby Born from 27-Year-Old Embryo: What This Means for the Future - Healthline - December 21st, 2020
- 16 Natural Ways to Boost Fertility - Healthline - December 20th, 2020
- IRMS Jersey City Office - IRMS Reproductive Medicine - December 20th, 2020
- University of Miami researchers studying effects of COVID-19 vaccine and male fertility - Newswise - December 20th, 2020
- Fantasia Barrino Gets Candid About Fertility Struggle: This Is A Three-Year Journey Weve Been On - ETCanada.com - December 20th, 2020
- Technological Advancement in Fertility Drug Market 2020 with Growth Analysis of Global Market & Forecast to 2026 - LionLowdown - December 20th, 2020
- Jackelyn B. Payne, MPH, MA, on Fertility Preservation in AYAs with Cancer - Cancer Network - December 18th, 2020
- Physicians Weigh in on TikToker's Claim That Mucinex Improves Fertility - Complex - December 18th, 2020
- Australia's first birth control app has been approved by the TGA. Do they work? - ABC News - December 18th, 2020
- Hitting the pause button: More women exploring fertility options amid ongoing pandemic - WZZM13.com - December 18th, 2020
- Why avoiding a nation-wide two-child policy is the right decision - Business Standard - December 18th, 2020
- Progyny CEO on the future of fertility treatments amid COVID-19 - Yahoo Finance - December 18th, 2020
- Covid vaccine and fertility: What you need to know - Metro.co.uk - December 18th, 2020
- EXCLUSIVE: Dr Aswati Nair on the link between obesity and male fertility - PINKVILLA - December 11th, 2020
- Assessing the impacts of global climate change on population trends - Newswise - December 11th, 2020
- Breast Cancer in Childbearing Years: Fertility Preservation Prior to Treatment Improves Outcomes for Survivors - Oncology Nurse Advisor - December 9th, 2020
- Apollo Fertility expands into Kolkata with a state-of-the-art Centre - PR Newswire India - December 9th, 2020