Dutch docu-series Seeds of Deceit tells the disturbing story of Dr. Jan Karbaat, a pioneer in the field of artificial insemination who secretly used his own sperm to impregnate his patients.
Across three episodes, director Miriam Guttmann weaves a complex narrative which balances the perspectives of the women abused by Karbaat, the dozens of children he fathered, and the superdonors who returned to his clinic over and over again to illegally spread their seed far and wide.
Seeds of Deceit was the first Dutch series ever to debut at Sundance and is now positioned for a global sales foray as one of the Series Market Selects at Berlinale.
Variety caught up with Guttmann and Monique Busman, who co-produced alongside Michiel van Erp, to discuss the shows jaw-dropping revelations and their thoughts on how to ensure that Karbaat and his friends twisted actions will never be repeated.
What compelled you to explore the story of Dr. Karbaat and his clinic?
MG: The headline, Fertility doctor has produced children using his own sperm immediately caught my attention; its sensational. But at the same time, I was even more curious about how this news affected the children and the mothers and I really wanted to dive into those personal stories. I think its a very layered story: the first layer is really sensational, its about sperm, but then when you dig deeper, its about identity and nature-nurture and is blood thicker than water, what makes family. Those themes we can all relate to; we are all the results of upbringing. I really tried to go beyond the sensation.
Its interesting how some of the mothers describe Karbaat as a seedy creep, while others paint him as a caring man.
MG: Hes a very complex figure; he has multiple faces. On the one hand, hes this really friendly, charming doctor. He was ahead of his time, he helped lesbians and single moms have children when no-one else did. But on the other hand, he abused women and used his position of power. He falsified donor passports and he made donors come back for years although the law was 25 children per donor at the time. The zeitgeist has really changed because I think he and his former colleagues could have never expected that there are now DNA tests and people can easily find their biological parents.
Since the revelations about Karbaats clinic, there have been reports from around the world of fertility doctors also using their own sperm to inseminate patients and superdonors fathering dozens of children. Why is this such a persistent issue?
MB: Its absolutely a huge problem still today. There are not good rules and laws to stop it from happening.
MG: The law changed in 2004 so people cannot donate anonymously anymore, but theres no central registration. Donors can still go to several clinics. Internationally, theres no central registration, and theres also the whole private sector where donors can just donate online. There was a guy a few weeks ago in the Netherlands who has 250 children. Hes donating to women online. Its a warning to show what can happen when there are not enough laws and rules.
Louis, a regular donor to Karbaats clinic who now has countless biological children, reveals in the series that his motivation behind donating over and over was to be seen as a pharaoh building his pyramid. What was your reaction when he said that?
MG: Of course it is wild and I was shocked, but I really tried to connect with all of my characters and step behind them. What I find very relatable is the fact that one wants to be remembered. I think we all want to be remembered, we all want to have mattered, we all want to have a funeral where there are many people. They dont all have to be descendants of course, but thats what I find very sympathetic. You can say that he had a god complex, but apparently there are men around the world who have this urge to procreate.
MB: Its devastating to realize that if you do this and you dont know how many children you have in the world, maybe they fall in love with each other? The impact is big, its incredible.
Do you think any of them stopped to think of the wider consequences of their actions?
MG: I think the times have completely changed. In Karbaats last interview, which is partly cited in this series, he literally says I never thought about the children and them all being half brothers or sisters. In the 70s and 80s semen used to be fresh, there was no way to freeze it. The donors would come on their bicycle, the doctor would get the sperm from them and inseminate the patients right away. I also heard from a former employee that the logistics were really hard, sometimes there would just be no donor available and then a doctor would just do the job. I think that it started that way and then he just lost it. He also impregnated women with water instead of sperm so thats a financial motive, but then he asked for pictures of children, so thats more the memorial kind of angle.
In the first episode, an anonymous former patient alleges that Karbaat raped her on the operating table. That must have been a difficult interview to conduct?
MG: I found that very shocking. Its another Me Too story and it happened behind closed doors. The wish of these women to become mothers was so strong that they let this happen and kept it a secret also was really shocking to find. We had a viewing with all the characters involved and it was powerful for the women to find out that they were not the only ones. It gave sort of a sense of recognition and community in a weird way because they had this secret for all these years. They had so many secrets like the big one towards their children that they were not the biological children of their legal dads. Its really important that this story now is finally being told.
You show that many of Karbaats children have come together and some are seeking compensation from the doctors family. What do you see as the future of this issue?
MG: I think that many of the Karbaat children after three years are already a little numb towards such a big group which is only getting bigger. They pick their favorite half-brothers and half-sisters because its just so overwhelming. You cant have 70 best friends. But I think the beautiful side of it is that they really have this sense of belonging and recognition, which they never had in their own families. They couldnt recognize themselves in their legal fathers, they couldnt recognize themselves in their siblings at home. Now theyre full grown-ups, but they really connect with one another and they have the same humor. They have this sense of grounding I think they never had. It also made me realize how privileged I am and fortunate that I was always able to recognize myself in my dad. We really look alike and that gives you structure. Its the simple fact is that you know where you come from, we all take for granted. When you dont have that it really has an impact on the rest of your life.
- The Risk and Opportunity of Online Fertility Groups - The Atlantic - July 23rd, 2022
- Insights on the Fertility Test United States Market to 2027 - Players Include Vio Health Tech, Fairhaven Health, Hamilton Thorne and Hilin Life... - July 23rd, 2022
- Financial costs for fertility care: Decoding the hidden hardship - The Financial Express - July 23rd, 2022
- Fertility tips: Preventive measures for men and women to avoid infertility - Hindustan Times - July 23rd, 2022
- BLM seeks public comment on three proposed wild-horse fertility control research projects - KTVZ - July 23rd, 2022
- 5 signs that tell when you're fertile each month - Times of India - July 23rd, 2022
- 5 ways to optimize your health before pregnancy, according to an OBGYN - Motherly Inc. - July 23rd, 2022
- National Leader in Reproductive Health Leads Effort to Recruit Medical Professionals into the Growing Fertility Healthcare Space - PR Newswire - July 23rd, 2022
- S. Korea's Total Fertility Rate Lowest in the World for 3rd Consecutive Year - The Korea Bizwire - July 23rd, 2022
- Girl, 14, with cancer given innovative fertility preservation surgery in London first - Yahoo News UK - July 23rd, 2022
- What is unexplained infertility? Here are some possible causes you need to know - Hindustan Times - July 23rd, 2022
- How exposure to toxic chemicals in everyday products can impact reproductive health - The 19th* - July 23rd, 2022
- People trying to get pregnant turn to period tracking apps for help and community - Los Angeles Times - July 23rd, 2022
- Too Late for The.. When Rafael Nadal Hilariously Reacted to a Joke About Fertility in an Exhibition Match Against Novak Djokovic - EssentiallySports - July 23rd, 2022
- Livestrong Fertility Program | Livestrong - July 7th, 2022
- Fertility fraud is legal in Michigan. Lawmakers are looking to change that. - MLive.com - July 7th, 2022
- Trade, family formation, and fertility in low-fertility settings | VOX, CEPR Policy Portal - voxeu.org - July 7th, 2022
- Both women and men can benefit from acupuncture when trying to conceive - Motherly Inc. - July 7th, 2022
- Male Fertility Test: How Men Can Check Their Fertility (And Why They Might Want To) - GQ - July 7th, 2022
- Fertility's freefall hastened by pandemic - The Catholic Weekly - July 7th, 2022
- Google to Automatically Remove User Destinations to Abortion and Fertility Clinics From History - Inside Edition - July 7th, 2022
- Eggs and sperm can now be stored for up to 55 years heres what that means for donors and people seeking fertility treatment - The Conversation... - July 7th, 2022
- Fertility and infertility: Definition and epidemiology - PubMed - June 15th, 2022
- A new era in the economics of fertility | VOX, CEPR Policy Portal - voxeu.org - June 15th, 2022
- Boost Fertility in Your 30s With 8 Easy, Actionable Tips - Camille Styles - June 15th, 2022
- Fertility firm boss happy to have the chat with potential suitors - Sydney Morning Herald - June 15th, 2022
- Baby Fever season 1 review - a wholesome but complicated dramedy on fertility - Ready Steady Cut - June 15th, 2022
- Fertility on ice: The cost of freezing your eggs - Money magazine - June 15th, 2022
- Employer fertility benefits are on the rise amid the Great Resignation - MSNBC - June 6th, 2022
- Heres How Microplastics Pose Risk To Womens Health And Fertility | Femina.in - Femina - June 6th, 2022
- How Abortion Decisions Could Impact IVF, According To A Fertility Doctor Whos Done It - Refinery29 - June 6th, 2022
- Environmental hazards and intoxicants impact fertility and overall TFR - Daily Pioneer - June 6th, 2022
- Fighting infertility? Obesity can affect fertility in men and women; check how you can increase your chances o - Times Now - June 6th, 2022
- Why We Need Gender-Inclusive Terms for 'Father' and 'Mother' - VICE - January 11th, 2022
- Do the COVID-19 vaccines affect my chances of pregnancy? - November 15th, 2021
- COVID-19 Q&A: Addressing concerns about fertility and the vaccine - WVTM13 - November 15th, 2021
- Shady Grove Fertility (SGF) to host donor egg treatment webinar for patients from the United Kingdom - PR Web - November 15th, 2021
- Fertile man formally charged in Oklee shooting - Thief River Falls Northern Watch - November 15th, 2021
- Expert: We have zero evidence COVID-19 vaccine affects fertility - WNEM Saginaw - November 4th, 2021
- Jewish Fertility Foundation hosts formal kick-off event Nov 4 - Village Living - November 4th, 2021
- Colorado Fertility Mandate Will Not Go Into Effect On January 1, 2022 - Above the Law - November 4th, 2021
- Get the Facts on the Vax: Viewer questions answered about the COVID-19 vaccine for kids 5-11 - KCRA Sacramento - November 4th, 2021
- It took me six years of IVF and two miscarriages to realise fertility support in the UK is broken - The Independent - November 4th, 2021
- Over one third of employers fail to offer fertility support - COVER - November 4th, 2021
- Chemicals found in everyday products found to be harmful to fertility - Mega Doctor News - November 4th, 2021
- Global Sperm Bank Market Size & Share to Clock Impressive GrowthProjected to Reach USD 5970.0 Million by 2027 - GlobeNewswire - November 4th, 2021
- Fertility Concerns And Breakthrough Infections: Debunking Common Myths About COVID Vaccines - WYPR - August 26th, 2021
- The fertility industry is poorly regulated and would-be parents can lose out on having children as a result - Westport News - August 26th, 2021
- What You Need To Know About Pregnancy, Fertility And The COVID-19 Vaccine - WBHM - August 26th, 2021
- I didnt want to burn a year of fertility: The pandemic postponed their weddings. But not their babies - The Boston Globe - August 26th, 2021
- Remote Work Is Creating a Digital Divide in Fertility - The Atlantic - August 26th, 2021
- Beijing wants women to have more babies. So why isn't it loosening rules on egg freezing? - CNN - August 26th, 2021
- Australia's fertility rate is at a record low. This expert says it's a disaster waiting to happen - ABC News - August 26th, 2021
- South Korea's Total Fertility Rate Continuing to Fall - BusinessKorea - August 26th, 2021
- Fertility Matters Canada Announces First-of-its-Kind National Event to Raise Awareness for the Unspoken Side of Fertility - Canada NewsWire - August 26th, 2021
- What do we know about Covid-19 vaccines and fertility? - Full Fact - August 26th, 2021
- Couple with unexplained fertility given 3% chance of conceiving welcome 'miracle' baby - The Mirror - August 26th, 2021
- 'Darcey & Stacey': Stacey Silva and Florian Sukaj Have a Conversation After Seeing a Fertility Doctor: 'We Have to Go Through This Whole Process,... - August 26th, 2021
- Ontario's Top Doc Says There Is 'No Evidence' That A COVID-19 Vaccine Will Affect Your Fertility - Narcity Canada - August 26th, 2021
- On Indias population, let the data speak - The Indian Express - August 26th, 2021
- Merz and Israeli Start-Up Vensica Launch Partnership for Needleless Treatment of Overactive Bladder - Business Wire - August 12th, 2021
- FACT CHECK: Do COVID-19 vaccines hamper fertility in unmarried women? - Internatinal Centre For Investigative Reporting - July 29th, 2021
- Ovation Fertility Deploys Matcher Across Its Nationwide Network of IVF and Genetics Labs - GlobeNewswire - July 29th, 2021
- The Promise and Perils of the New Fertility Entrepreneurs - The New Yorker - May 23rd, 2021
- Does the COVID-19 vaccine in teens, young adults pose fertility risks? - WCVB Boston - May 23rd, 2021
- Scott Winship: Don't Believe Horror Stories About Fertility Rates, Income Inequality, and Economic Mobility - Reason - May 23rd, 2021
- From A Fertility Doctor: Why I Believe Misinformation Is A Leading Cause Of Infertility - Scary Mommy - May 23rd, 2021
- Hysteria over declining fertility rates is just another manifestation of white supremacy - Thought Leader - May 23rd, 2021
- How to keep stress and anxiety at bay during your fertility treatment amid the COVID 19 crisis? - PINKVILLA - May 23rd, 2021
- Should we use fewer condoms to boost fertility? EJINSIGHT - EJ Insight - May 23rd, 2021
- 'I Started Fertility Treatment Alone And In Another Country' The Reality Of Trying For A Baby Alone In A Pandemic - Grazia - April 7th, 2021
- PCOS and Fertility: What women can do about it? - The Tribune India - March 10th, 2021
- Coronavirus and fertility - Modern Diplomacy - March 10th, 2021
- Hilaria Baldwin and the Strange Allure of Celebrity Fertility - The New York Times - March 10th, 2021
- Biblical fertility amulet found by 11-year-old in the Negev - The Jerusalem Post - March 10th, 2021
- COVID-19 vaccine side effects: Can any COVID shots affect fertility? Here is all you need to know - Times Now - March 10th, 2021
- BLEVINS: Good fertility will help insure productive pastures - Bristol Herald Courier - March 10th, 2021
- No Smoking Day 2021: Impact of Smoking on Fertility and Childbirth - News18 - March 10th, 2021
- Grieving for the family I never had: When fertility treatment fails - Yahoo Sports - March 10th, 2021
- Is deceased Cincinnati fertility doctor the missing link for these newly discovered half-siblings? - WCPO - March 10th, 2021