A review of Social Reproduction Theory and the Socialist Horizon: Work, Power and Political Strategy, Aaron Jaffe (Pluto Press, 2020), 18.99
Social Reproduction Theory and the Socialist Horizon by Aaron Jaffe is another book in the Mapping Social Reproduction Theory series, which is edited by Tithi Bhattacharya. The strengths in Jaffes account of social reproduction theory (SRT) are threefold: his clarity about the competitive drive for accumulation in all capitalist societies; his critique of gender essentialism; and his sensitive critique of intersectionality. The weaknesses lie in not using all the tools in the Marxist toolbox, particularly in relation to racism and the state.
Jaffe sees his analysis of SRT as a development of Marxism that can help us provide accurate analyses of the world we live in, develop social criticism and point towards a socialist horizon of emancipation. SRT is not confined to being a theory about womens oppression: Social reproduction is best understood not as a term singling out some distinct content, but as a framework for investigating and understanding the world, with particular attention paid to the way our embodied labour powers are made and sustained. At the heart of Jaffes argument for SRT is the need to oppose a version of Marxism that reduces the analysis of capitalism to looking at the the valorisation process, that is, how surplus value is pumped out of the direct producers:
It is obvious that a value-centred account is limited. In order to provide more specific and grounded accounts of values role in particular contexts, we need to study actual social relations, as well as their histories.
Of course this is true, but it is unclear whether Jaffe thinks Karl Marx himself was lacking or that only some developments of Marxism are. I would argue that Marx and Friedrich Engels, as well as some others since, went well beyond a value-centred account.
Jaffe grounds SRT in a development of the concept of labour power taken from Marx: By labour power or capacity for labour is to be understood the aggregate of those mental and physical abilities existing in a human being that he [sic] exercises whenever he produces a use value of any description. As Jaffe points out, this is a broad definition of labour power that goes well beyond the sale of labour power for the production of surplus value. Instead, Labour powers are those capacities that produce everything we find valuable. So human needs and our labour powers or labour capacities are developed or stunted depending on the particular society we live in; they are socially and historically shaped. Central to capitalist exploitation is the difference between those who have to sell their capacity for labour to live and those who buy the capacity for labour.
Analysing the social forces that determine whether and how our labour capacities are nurtured and developed, or stunted and neglected, acts as a way of assessing the nature of different kinds of oppression and the impact of exploitation. It enables a judgement, for example, about the limitations of actually existing socialism. It also shows how racism, sexism, transphobia and disability oppression hold people back in particular ways. Additionally, this concept of labour capacities points to the ways in which society would have to change for everyone to realise their maximum potential.
Jaffe has a chapter on gender and the body in which he carefully analyses these aspects in Caliban and the Witch by Silvia Federici and Marxism and the Oppression of Women by Lise Vogel, which is the foundational text for many SRT theorists. He shows that Federici takes no account of real historical developments in the emergence of capitalism. The problem, according to Jaffe, is that Federici posits the existence of a pre-capitalist natural body that had to be deformed to ensure women became reproducers of labour power. Liberation, for Federici, would mean reverting to that natural body. However, this reliance on the idea of a biologically sexed female body makes it difficult to develop a non-binary, trans and lesbian and gay inclusive approach to gender and overlooks the gendered body as a possible site of self-determination.
Lise Vogels account of womens oppression is, according to Jaffe, both more open and more closed than Federicis. Vogel analyses the way in which women are constrained historically by capitalist conditions. However, she relies purely on womens child bearing capacity to explain how women are disadvantaged in the capitalist labour market, locating this as the root cause of womens oppression. Moreover, Vogel fails to explore the relation between sex, biology and gender. Jaffe concludes, Though accurate for many women, rooting gender oppression as a whole in biologically reproductive powers assumes too much about gender, andrisks rendering the category women and womens oppression in a biologically essentialist way.
Jaffes criticisms are important, so it is disappointing that he fails to point to other accounts of womens oppression, particularly those that build on Engelss classic The Origin of the Family, Private Property and the State. Engels provides an explanation of womens oppression with his analysis of the construction of the family as the site of the privatised reproduction of labour power under capitalism. Engelss analysis, and the research of later theorists based on his insights, has the advantage of locating the reproduction of labour power in relation to the accumulation of capital. Rooted in an analysis of historical developments, these accounts provide powerful tools for understanding how the gender binary is constructed under capitalism and how LGBT+ oppression emerges.
In his chapter on intersectionality, Jaffe states: I consider SRT to be best suited to tackling the interwoven nature of oppressions in capitalist societies, because it highlights the central role played by class in these oppressions. He acknowledges the rich roots of theories of intersectionality in black feminism. However, he prefers SRT (quite rightly) over the best of intersectional approaches because it provides an overall framework for situating all oppressions, pointing to the central role of accumulation in the class relations of exploitation. SRT answers the why question, whereas intersectionality remains at the level of description. Jaffe quotes Marxs description of historical materialism in his unfinished third volume of Capital in order to reinforce this argument:
The specific economic form in which unpaid surplus-labour is pumped out of direct producers determines the relationship of rulers and ruled, as it grows directly out of production itself and, in turn, reacts upon it as a determining element. Upon this, however, is founded the entire formation of the economic community that grows up out of the production relations themselves, and thereby simultaneously its specific political form. It is always the direct relationship of the owners of the conditions of production to the direct producersa relation always naturally corresponding to a definite stage in the development of the methods of labour and thereby its social productivitythat reveals the innermost secret, the hidden basis of the entire social structure and with it the political form of the relation of sovereignty and dependence: in short, the corresponding specific form of the state. This does not prevent the same economic basisthe same from the standpoint of its main conditions from showing infinite variations and gradations in appearance due to innumerably different empirical circumstances such as natural environment, racial relations, external historical influences and so on. These can be ascertained only by analysis of the empirically given circumstances.
This does provide the framework, I agree, for developing the social and historical analysis of different kinds of oppression, whether they emerged with capitalism, as with racism and what Jaffe calls ableism, or with the rise of class society itself, as with womens oppression. However, Jaffe says Marx rejected a unidirectional notion of causality, yet Marx seems to do the opposite with the parameters he sets out in the above. For example, modern capitalist societies can exist with different forms of the nuclear familyheterosexual, homosexual, single parent, married, unmarriedbut none of those varying forms undermines the reality of the privatised reproduction of labour power. Meanwhile, the intensifying crisis in ageing capitalism has led increasingly to cuts to a vast array of social support systems developed for the reproduction of labour power. Social forms may react back upon economic relations, but economic relations condition and limit these social forms in a much more determinate sense.
So where are the weaknesses in Jaffes theorisation of SRT? First, they lie in failing to use more of Marxs and Engelss writings on oppression. Jaffe argues that not doing so makes SRT seem less of a threat to Marxists, though he uses some references to help to convince sceptics. I think the opposite is the case, and that much is missed by taking this approach; Marxs and Engelss writings are replete with discussions about women and children, and the relationship between Irish and English workers. They also analyse the impact of colonialism in binding English workers to their ruling class and the importance of slave revolts and the Civil War in the United States. Marxs own articulation of the role of systemic racism and slavery is convincing and powerful: Labour cannot emancipate itself in the white skin where in the black it is branded. For Marx the self-emancipation of the working class cannot happen without overcoming all manner of divisions. Reductive and deterministic strands in Marxism encapsulated by Karl Kautskys and Stalins interpretations of Marxism should not mask Marxs own position (nor that of Engels) nor that of the revolutionary socialist tradition. It is surely important to reassert, albeit critically, Marxs own approach.
Second, Jaffe emphasises the role of processes of social reproduction and downplays the role of the ruling class in crafting the mainsprings of oppression. The working-class family did not simply emerge from nowhere in the late 19th centuryit was actively promoted. What is more, governments use legislation to ensure the continuation of the privatised reproduction of labour power, intervening ideologically at different points to argue for the family and family vaues. This is precisely why the question of abortion is always a key weapon for the right.
To take another example, racism has taken many different forms in the US and Europe, from the Jim Crow laws in the Reconstruction period after the US Civil War to the rise of antisemitism and immigration controls, the promotion of Islamophobia, and the institutional racism that continues today. These profoundly impact daily life, as demonstrated by the 2020 Black Lives Matter movement after the racist police murder of George Floyd in Minneapolis, Minnesota. However, all these forms of racism have been consciously developed by the ruling class as strategies to divide workers. Of course, some workers behave in ways that are sexist, racist, Islamophobic, homophobic, transphobic and so on, and such prejudices have to be challenged. Yet, these views do not arise spontaneously. Workers are not born thinking that way, any more than women are oppressed because of their ability to give birth.
The failure to locate the use of racism, sexism, transphobia and other forms of oppression in the conscious strategies of the ruling class is the reverse side of the coin of ignoring the impact of divisions on the working class. The latter approach leads to disregarding the need to combat racist, sexist, homophobic and transphobic attitudes. However, focusing only on social reproduction leads to under-theorising the role of the state and politics in the institutionalisation of different kinds of oppression. This can move the focus of socialists away from those responsible for promoting divisive strategies. Donald Trump deliberately helped build the far right during the four years of his presidency; in Britain, Boris Johnson is consciously implementing sexist and racist policies, scapegoating refugees and migrants, and attacking the right of oppressed groups to protest. Theoretically, SRT simply does not match up to the actuality of the Black Lives Matter movement that challenged the institutionalised racism of the police and the wider capitalist state.
Jaffe is right to celebrate recent struggles around the world, particularly the re-emergence of the strike weapon. Indeed, he would have strengthened his argument if he had drawn out the significance of mass strikes as what Rosa Luxemburg called the method of motion of the proletarian mass, which is fundamental to the Marxist view of the self-emanciaption of the working class. These workers struggles, alongside the Black Lives Matter movement in 2020, the anti-sexist demonstrations after the murder of Sarah Everard by a police officer in Britain in March 2021 and the global Palestinian solidarity movement of May 2020, demonstrate the potentiality for overcoming divisions and give us a glimpse of what Lenin meant when he called revolution the festival of the oppressed. Self-emancipation is about having a vision of a totally different kind of society. However, that society is unachievable without winning robust arguments about the need to overthrow the capitalist state and drawing on strategic approaches from the revolutionary socialist tradition such as the united front method and the building of revolutionary organisation.
Sheila McGregor is a long-standing member of the Socialist Workers Party (SWP) and a member of the International Socialism editorial board.
Continued here:
Revisiting social reproduction theory International Socialism - International Socialism Journal
- Women Are Sharing How Little The Men In Their Lives Know About Reproduction - HuffPost - May 18th, 2022
- Review: 'Men' an arty horror film that stumbles in the woods - Star Tribune - May 18th, 2022
- The baffling truth about hammerhead worms in Ohio - WJW FOX 8 News Cleveland - May 18th, 2022
- PSHE KS2: Operation Ouch! How are babies made? Sperm, egg and reproductive organs - BBC - May 18th, 2022
- Opinion: Biological Science Rejects the Sex Binary, and Thats Good for Humanity - The Scientist - May 18th, 2022
- Opinion | Dont Be Fooled. Its All About Women and Sex. - The New York Times - May 18th, 2022
- Why abortion is deeply rooted in the history of humankind - EL PAS in English - May 18th, 2022
- ZooTampa Celebrates Rare Birth Of Litter Of Nearly Extinct Red Wolves - Patch - May 18th, 2022
- Abortion, Trans Health Care, and Right-Wing Pro-Natalism - The Intercept - May 18th, 2022
- Absent for More Than a Century, California Condors Soar Above the Redwoods Again - National Audubon Society - May 18th, 2022
- Male birth control: Why are condoms and vasectomies the only options? - USA TODAY - May 18th, 2022
- The Normalcy of White Male Violence - The Cut - May 18th, 2022
- Abortion rights groups have outraised foes. Will it help in midterms? - USA TODAY - May 18th, 2022
- Improving Women Economic Empowerment To Boost National Development - - The Tide - May 18th, 2022
- Is cannabis for womens pain as harmless as you think? Its time to look at the evidence - Geektime - April 22nd, 2022
- PINNACLE FERTILITY JOINS NATIONAL INFERTILITY AWARENESS WEEK TO RAISE AWARENESS AND EMPOWER THE INFERTILITY COMMUNITY - Yahoo Finance - April 22nd, 2022
- Minnesota bears may be fat and happy, rather than at risk - Star Tribune - April 22nd, 2022
- Diamond mines in the Northwest Territories are not a girls best friend - The Conversation - April 22nd, 2022
- Sacred hares, banished winter witches and pagan worship the roots of Easter Bunny traditions are ancient - Iowa Capital Dispatch - April 22nd, 2022
- RUDN University: Providing Young Generation With Excellent Professional Skills And Knowledge - Modern Diplomacy - April 22nd, 2022
- Higher risk of premenstrual disorders is seen with higher BMI in childhood - Contemporary Pediatrics - April 22nd, 2022
- Plastic pollution could make much of humanity infertile, experts fear - Salon - March 28th, 2022
- Reproductive and postsurgical outcomes of infertile women with deep infiltrating endometriosis - BMC Women's Health - BioMed Central - March 28th, 2022
- Decay of homologous chromosome pairs and discovery of males in the thelytokous fungus-growing ant Mycocepurus smithii | Scientific Reports -... - March 28th, 2022
- What is that noise in my woods? Explosion of amphibious reproduction underway in a vernal pool near you - News 5 Cleveland WEWS - March 28th, 2022
- Game Commission researchers find the oldest-recorded wild turkey in Pennsylvania history - WPMT FOX 43 - March 28th, 2022
- Endometriosis and Your Hormones: What's the Link? - Healthline - March 28th, 2022
- What is mitochondrial donation, and what do you need to know about it? - ABC News - March 28th, 2022
- Why gender perspectives must be included in the study of artificial intelligence - Equal Times - March 28th, 2022
- Innovent and Lilly Expand Strategic Partnership in Oncology - StreetInsider.com - March 28th, 2022
- A narwhal is still swimming with a pod of belugas in the St. Lawrence. Is this the year a narluga will be conceived? - The Globe and Mail - March 28th, 2022
- The people cloning their pets - BBC.com - March 28th, 2022
- Female dolphins have a clitoris much like humans - Science News Magazine - January 11th, 2022
- The significant role of post-pairing male behavior on the evolution of male preferences and female traits | Communications Biology - Nature.com - January 11th, 2022
- Ireland's baby-making business: From egg freezing to IVF and everything in between - The Irish Times - January 11th, 2022
- Ridding Canadian medicine of conversion therapy - CMAJ - January 11th, 2022
- The metabolic cost of turning right side up in the Mediterranean spur-thighed tortoise (Testudo graeca) | Scientific Reports - Nature.com - January 11th, 2022
- Gender Bias In Futuristic Technologies: A Probe Into AI & Inclusive Solutions - Feminism in India - January 11th, 2022
- Malta among top performers in fertility treatment, but offers no education programme - Newsbook - January 11th, 2022
- 'Tinted With You' Is the Bite-Sized BL Web Drama We're Loving Right Now - Hornet - January 11th, 2022
- Wondrous and amazing: female California condors can reproduce without males - The Guardian - November 4th, 2021
- The egg freezing conundrum in Singapore not all social and ethical issues can be regulated by law - BioNews - November 4th, 2021
- Rosanna Davison: Im still waiting two years later to apply to be my daughters guardian - The Irish Times - November 4th, 2021
- Rosanna Davison reveals she's still waiting to apply to be her daughter's legal guardian - Goss.ie - November 4th, 2021
- Fish and Game looks to improve alpine fisheries with 'super-male' brook trout - Idaho Mountain Express and Guide - November 4th, 2021
- This chemical could be stopping you from getting pregnant. What is it? - The Jerusalem Post - October 5th, 2021
- Protesters in Rock Island rally against anti-abortion laws - WQAD.com - October 5th, 2021
- Inside Female Dating Strategy, the Subreddit That Teaches Women to Level Up Against Scrotes and F*ckboys - Jezebel - October 5th, 2021
- Abortion testimonials from women in Congress punctuate hearing on SB8, the Texas bounty law - The Dallas Morning News - October 5th, 2021
- 2018 Camp Fire prompts 'true experiment of nature' - The Aggie - The Aggie - October 5th, 2021
- If it only depends on the brain, women can consume more alcohol than men The Clare People - The Clare People - October 5th, 2021
- To Fight Texass Abortion Law, These Houston Hospitality Veterans are Teaming Up - Eater Houston - October 5th, 2021
- Back-Seat Driver: The Parasite That Makes Bees Drop Off Its Babies - Entomology Today - October 5th, 2021
- Scientists Find A Species That Survived For Thousands of Years Without Having Sex - The Swaddle - October 5th, 2021
- October Weed of the Month: Red Hailstone - redlakenationnews.com - October 5th, 2021
- Barbie sent a doll on a zero-gravity flight to inspire young girls to work in space and STEM - Screen Shot - October 5th, 2021
- Amia Srinivasan What does Fluffy think? Pets with Benefits LRB 7 October 2021 - London Review of Books - October 5th, 2021
- New report sounds the alarm on global shortage of 900 000 midwives - World Health Organization - World Health Organization - May 10th, 2021
- Australian Treasurer to Address Women's Safety, Health in Budget - Bloomberg - May 10th, 2021
- A lot of shame: Why we need to talk about male infertility - TVO - May 10th, 2021
- Restricting abortion access fizzled in the 2021 Legislature; reproductive rights advocates expect future battles - Florida Phoenix - May 10th, 2021
- Op-Ed: How to change a health system that harms Black mothers - Los Angeles Times - May 10th, 2021
- COVID-19 Vaccination in Pregnant and Nursing Women: Expert Perspectives From Obstetrics and Epidemiology - Infectious Disease Advisor - May 10th, 2021
- Reproductive Rights Advocates Call for Biden to Curb Foreign Abortion Restrictions - Ms. Magazine - May 10th, 2021
- Newsday panel: Pregnant women, those seeking to get pregnant should get the COVID-19 vaccines - Newsday - May 10th, 2021
- Women at work on Mothers Day The Manila Times - The Manila Times - May 10th, 2021
- Time to cut the string on the global reproductive health yo-yo | TheHill - The Hill - May 10th, 2021
- Cancer threatened N.J. womans dream of motherhood. Then her sister stepped in. - NJ.com - May 10th, 2021
- CU Boulder Study Finds That Better Access To Birth Control Boosts High School Graduation Rates - Colorado Public Radio - May 10th, 2021
- Linking Voter Suppression and Abortion Restrictions: If We Lose Voting Rights, We Lose Women's Rights - Ms. Magazine - May 10th, 2021
- From Women's Health to Yemen Crisis: 6 Key Issues Hit by UK Aid Cuts - Global Citizen - May 10th, 2021
- Are chemicals shrinking your penis and depleting your sperm? Heres what the evidence really says - News24 - May 10th, 2021
- The Semester That Was The Badger Herald - UW Badger Herald - May 10th, 2021
- Focus on anti-abortion policies is a waste of resources, hurts Texans' health - Abilene Reporter-News - May 10th, 2021
- Ferring, Rebiotix and MyBiotics Collaborate to Develop Live Microbiome-Based Therapeutics in Reproductive Medicine and Maternal Health - BioSpace - February 17th, 2021
- One in 10 Ohio women thought abortion illegal amid attempts to ban at 6 weeks - The Ohio State University News - February 17th, 2021
- Bia-Echo Foundation invest $8M in Singapore to study women's reproductive longevity - BSA bureau - February 17th, 2021
- Now is the Time for the Biden Administration to Commit to Upholding Reproductive Rights as Human Rights - Just Security - February 17th, 2021
- Severe Physical Intimate Partner Violence Linked to Mental Disorders in Black Women - Psychiatry Advisor - February 17th, 2021
- $21.6 Billion Feminine Hygiene Products Markets - Global Industry Trends, Share, Size, Growth, Opportunity and Forecast to 2026 -... - February 17th, 2021