A doomsday scenario of an end to human sperm production has been back in the news recently, now with the added threat of shrinking penises.
Professor Shanna Swan, a US epidemiologist who studies environmental influences on human development, recently published a new book called Countdown.
In it, she suggests sperm counts could reach zero by 2045, largely owing to the impact of a range of environmental pollutants used in manufacturing everyday products: phthalates and bisphosphenol A (BPA) from plastics, and per- and poly-fluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) used, for example, in waterproofing.
Under this scenario, she says, most couples wanting to conceive would need to rely on assisted reproductive technologies.
She has also warned these chemicals are shrinking penis size.
Such extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. I would argue the evidence is not strong enough.
Epidemiologists find associations between disease and potential contributing factors, like lung cancer and smoking. But their work cant identify the causes of disease just because two things are associated doesnt mean one is causing, or caused by, the other.
An article written by environmental activist Erin Brockovich in The Guardian in March leads by referring to hormone-disrupting chemicals that are decimating fertility. But causation is far from established.
Its reasonable to expect chemicals that affect hormone function in our bodies, like BPA and PFAS, could affect reproduction in males and females, given available evidence. But we dont have irrefutable proof.
In 2017, Swan and several colleagues published an exhaustive review study showing an apparent drop in mens sperm counts of 59.3% between 1973 and 2011. This research informs the arguments Swan makes in Countdown and those weve seen in the media.
Whats not often mentioned is the fact the researchers only observed a decline in sperm count in groups of men from North America, Europe, Australia, and New Zealand, but not in groups of men from South America, Asia or Africa.
When Swan and her colleagues combined the data from all countries, they saw a decline because the studies of Western men outweigh those of men elsewhere (in the number of studies and participants).
Swan and her colleagues worked hard to avoid bias when conducting their study. But selection bias (related to how study participants are chosen), publication bias (resulting from researchers tendency to report only observations they think will be of interest) and other limitations of the original work used as the basis for their investigation could be influencing the results of the larger study.
Many studies from different parts of the world show declining sperm counts, which is concerning, but we dont fully understand the reasons for the apparent decline. Blaming chemicals in the environment overlooks other important factors such as chronic disease, diet, and obesity, which people can act on to improve their fertility.
Swans 2017 study boils down to a straight descending line drawn between sperm counts of groups of men studied at different times between 1973 and 2011.
Just because a straight line can be drawn through the data, this doesnt justify extrapolation of that line beyond its earliest and latest data points. Its unscientific to assume trends in data exist outside the range of observations.
We know sperm counts of men in the early 1940s were around 113 million sperm per ml of semen, not the roughly 140 million/ml you get from extrapolating backwards from Swans research. Concluding sperm counts will reach zero in 2045, based on extrapolating forward from the available data, is just as likely to be incorrect.
When Swan told news website Axios If you look at the curve on sperm count and project it forward she was encouraging unjustifiable and unscientific interpretation of her data even though she acknowledged it was risky to extrapolate in this way. Unfortunately this caution is too often unmentioned.
For example, Brockovich writes: That would mean no babies. No reproduction. No more humans. Thats hyperbole. Its just not science.
Claims of shrinking penises are obvious clickbait. But only a single study, of 383 young men from the Veneto region in northeastern Italy, links mens penis size to the types of chemicals Swan attributes to declining sperm counts.
Within Veneto there are geographic zones with varied levels of PFAS contamination. A group of 212 men who live in areas with high or intermediate PFAS exposure and have high levels of these chemicals in their bodies, had an average penis length of 8.6cm, about 10% lower than the average of a group of 171 men from an area without exposure (9.7cm).
But a few features of this study affect the reliability of the observations and whether we can generalise them to other populations.
men were grouped according to where they lived, not where they were born. Since genital size is determined before birth, the environment during their mothers pregnancies is more relevant to penis size than where the men lived at the time of the study. Some men will likely have relocated from their place of birth but how many, and where they may have moved to and from, we dont know
the levels of PFAS exposure for men living in the contaminated regions of Veneto are extreme, because of decades of industrial pollution. How the potential effect of such large exposures relates to smaller and more common exposures to pollutants, like from plastic food wrap, we dont know
the study is missing details about its subjects and the conditions under which measurements were made. Its usual to exclude people with conditions that might affect study outcomes, such as congenital abnormalities, but its not clear whether this happened in the study. Variables that influence penile measurements (such as room temperature, posture, and whether the penis is held straight or hanging) are not mentioned.
And from a semantic perspective, for penises to be shrinking they must be getting shorter over time, on either an individual or population basis. I cannot find any reports of mens penises shortening as a consequence of environmental pollution. Available data dont suggest a decline in penis size over the past few decades.
While environmental pollution is a pressing concern, the evidence suggests the catastrophic collapse of human reproduction and accompanying penis shrinkage is thankfully a pretty unlikely prospect.
Tim Moss, Adjunct Associate Professor, Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, Monash University
This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.
- Environmental Factor - July 2022: On the road again: NIEHS shines at the Endocrine Society's annual conference - Environmental Factor Newsletter - July 7th, 2022
- Overthrowing the Patriarchy Through Ecstatic Sex - Nautilus | Science Connected - Nautilus - July 7th, 2022
- A randomised controlled trial on the effects of a structural education module among women with polycystic ovarian syndrome on nutrition and physical... - July 7th, 2022
- Cockroaches are evolving to prefer low-sugar diets. That could be bad news for humans - Salon - July 7th, 2022
- Aquarium of the Pacific vet publishes findings on zebra shark artificial insemination Long Beach Post News - Long Beach Post - July 7th, 2022
- Opinion: Shattered trust in the Supreme Court will undermine every ruling - The Denver Post - July 7th, 2022
- Struggling with Infertility? The Mishpacha Project is here to help - Jewish News of Greater Phoenix - July 7th, 2022
- Mosquitoes sniff out hosts infected with certain viruses, researchers find - NBC News - July 7th, 2022
- GARDEN CORNER: Lighting up the night, these bugs need some protection - YourGV.com - July 7th, 2022
- The 12 Worst Endocrine Disruptors and How to Avoid Them - The Epoch Times - July 7th, 2022
- How beetles trick bees into feeding them food rich in nutrients - The Conversation - July 7th, 2022
- Rabbit Reproduction Basics - LafeberVet - June 25th, 2022
- Female orgasm | myVMC - June 25th, 2022
- 250,000 Year Old Insect Challenges Evolutionary Theory - The Epoch Times - June 25th, 2022
- Roe v Wade: men benefit from abortion rights too and should speak about them more - The Conversation - June 25th, 2022
- What is reproductive justice? Experts say it matters more than ever in a post-Roe world that is likely to disproportionately impact people of color -... - June 25th, 2022
- 'Sex in City Plants' reveals the secrets of urban reproduction - AIPT - June 25th, 2022
- 'Superwasp' Threatens America's Forests With Females Capable of Producing 1,000 Offspring - Newsweek - June 25th, 2022
- A CANADIAN SCIENTIST RECOGNIZED AS A L'ORAL-UNESCO FOR WOMEN IN SCIENCE INTERNATIONAL RISING TALENT 2022 - Yahoo Finance - June 25th, 2022
- Now That Roe v. Wade Has Been Overturned, Ratifying the ERA Is More Urgent Than Ever, Says Gloria Steinem - Oprah Mag - June 25th, 2022
- Increase in leptin levels in preeclampsia prompts cardiovascular cascade that puts mother and baby at risk - Jagwire Augusta - June 25th, 2022
- Abortion: Pro-Choice; Pro-Nothing; Pro-Life - Study the law with Blessed Mupatsi - Bulawayo24 News - June 25th, 2022
- All about the mites living and reproducing on your skin - Interesting Engineering - June 25th, 2022
- There's Convincing Evidence The Pill Can Cause Depression, And Some Types Are Worse Than Others - IFLScience - June 15th, 2022
- Evidence the pill causes depression - Cosmos - June 15th, 2022
- The Handmaid's Tale voted top book written by a woman for men to read - Cumnock Chronicle - June 15th, 2022
- 'Grease 2' turns 40: Why the 'more fun, female-forward' sequel is better than the original - USA TODAY - June 15th, 2022
- The Intriguing Life, Death, and Afterlife of an Indiana Mastodon - Atlas Obscura - June 15th, 2022
- New prehistoric plant discovery highlights the unexpected diversity of non-flowering plants - UM Today - June 15th, 2022
- Women Are Sharing How Little The Men In Their Lives Know About Reproduction - HuffPost - May 18th, 2022
- Review: 'Men' an arty horror film that stumbles in the woods - Star Tribune - May 18th, 2022
- The baffling truth about hammerhead worms in Ohio - WJW FOX 8 News Cleveland - May 18th, 2022
- PSHE KS2: Operation Ouch! How are babies made? Sperm, egg and reproductive organs - BBC - May 18th, 2022
- Opinion: Biological Science Rejects the Sex Binary, and Thats Good for Humanity - The Scientist - May 18th, 2022
- Opinion | Dont Be Fooled. Its All About Women and Sex. - The New York Times - May 18th, 2022
- Why abortion is deeply rooted in the history of humankind - EL PAS in English - May 18th, 2022
- ZooTampa Celebrates Rare Birth Of Litter Of Nearly Extinct Red Wolves - Patch - May 18th, 2022
- Abortion, Trans Health Care, and Right-Wing Pro-Natalism - The Intercept - May 18th, 2022
- Absent for More Than a Century, California Condors Soar Above the Redwoods Again - National Audubon Society - May 18th, 2022
- The Normalcy of White Male Violence - The Cut - May 18th, 2022
- Improving Women Economic Empowerment To Boost National Development - - The Tide - May 18th, 2022
- Is cannabis for womens pain as harmless as you think? Its time to look at the evidence - Geektime - April 22nd, 2022
- PINNACLE FERTILITY JOINS NATIONAL INFERTILITY AWARENESS WEEK TO RAISE AWARENESS AND EMPOWER THE INFERTILITY COMMUNITY - Yahoo Finance - April 22nd, 2022
- Minnesota bears may be fat and happy, rather than at risk - Star Tribune - April 22nd, 2022
- Diamond mines in the Northwest Territories are not a girls best friend - The Conversation - April 22nd, 2022
- Sacred hares, banished winter witches and pagan worship the roots of Easter Bunny traditions are ancient - Iowa Capital Dispatch - April 22nd, 2022
- RUDN University: Providing Young Generation With Excellent Professional Skills And Knowledge - Modern Diplomacy - April 22nd, 2022
- Higher risk of premenstrual disorders is seen with higher BMI in childhood - Contemporary Pediatrics - April 22nd, 2022
- Plastic pollution could make much of humanity infertile, experts fear - Salon - March 28th, 2022
- Reproductive and postsurgical outcomes of infertile women with deep infiltrating endometriosis - BMC Women's Health - BioMed Central - March 28th, 2022
- Decay of homologous chromosome pairs and discovery of males in the thelytokous fungus-growing ant Mycocepurus smithii | Scientific Reports -... - March 28th, 2022
- What is that noise in my woods? Explosion of amphibious reproduction underway in a vernal pool near you - News 5 Cleveland WEWS - March 28th, 2022
- Game Commission researchers find the oldest-recorded wild turkey in Pennsylvania history - WPMT FOX 43 - March 28th, 2022
- Endometriosis and Your Hormones: What's the Link? - Healthline - March 28th, 2022
- What is mitochondrial donation, and what do you need to know about it? - ABC News - March 28th, 2022
- Why gender perspectives must be included in the study of artificial intelligence - Equal Times - March 28th, 2022
- Innovent and Lilly Expand Strategic Partnership in Oncology - StreetInsider.com - March 28th, 2022
- A narwhal is still swimming with a pod of belugas in the St. Lawrence. Is this the year a narluga will be conceived? - The Globe and Mail - March 28th, 2022
- The people cloning their pets - BBC.com - March 28th, 2022
- Female dolphins have a clitoris much like humans - Science News Magazine - January 11th, 2022
- The significant role of post-pairing male behavior on the evolution of male preferences and female traits | Communications Biology - Nature.com - January 11th, 2022
- Revisiting social reproduction theory International Socialism - International Socialism Journal - January 11th, 2022
- Ireland's baby-making business: From egg freezing to IVF and everything in between - The Irish Times - January 11th, 2022
- Ridding Canadian medicine of conversion therapy - CMAJ - January 11th, 2022
- The metabolic cost of turning right side up in the Mediterranean spur-thighed tortoise (Testudo graeca) | Scientific Reports - Nature.com - January 11th, 2022
- Gender Bias In Futuristic Technologies: A Probe Into AI & Inclusive Solutions - Feminism in India - January 11th, 2022
- Malta among top performers in fertility treatment, but offers no education programme - Newsbook - January 11th, 2022
- 'Tinted With You' Is the Bite-Sized BL Web Drama We're Loving Right Now - Hornet - January 11th, 2022
- Wondrous and amazing: female California condors can reproduce without males - The Guardian - November 4th, 2021
- The egg freezing conundrum in Singapore not all social and ethical issues can be regulated by law - BioNews - November 4th, 2021
- Rosanna Davison: Im still waiting two years later to apply to be my daughters guardian - The Irish Times - November 4th, 2021
- Rosanna Davison reveals she's still waiting to apply to be her daughter's legal guardian - Goss.ie - November 4th, 2021
- Fish and Game looks to improve alpine fisheries with 'super-male' brook trout - Idaho Mountain Express and Guide - November 4th, 2021
- This chemical could be stopping you from getting pregnant. What is it? - The Jerusalem Post - October 5th, 2021
- Protesters in Rock Island rally against anti-abortion laws - WQAD.com - October 5th, 2021
- Inside Female Dating Strategy, the Subreddit That Teaches Women to Level Up Against Scrotes and F*ckboys - Jezebel - October 5th, 2021
- Abortion testimonials from women in Congress punctuate hearing on SB8, the Texas bounty law - The Dallas Morning News - October 5th, 2021
- 2018 Camp Fire prompts 'true experiment of nature' - The Aggie - The Aggie - October 5th, 2021
- If it only depends on the brain, women can consume more alcohol than men The Clare People - The Clare People - October 5th, 2021
- To Fight Texass Abortion Law, These Houston Hospitality Veterans are Teaming Up - Eater Houston - October 5th, 2021