The TechSubmit Campus Life Stories Campus Tips Blunt egg donor ad generates controversy among students, CSAIL By Drew Bent Apr. 20, 2017
An advertisement that ran in the March 23 issue of The Tech began Genius Asian Egg Donor Wanted, and offered $20,000, sparking a heated debate on campus and prompting a discussion on CSAILs general mailing list.
The person behind the ad is William Naylor, a Caltech alum and researcher who currently lives in Cupertino, California. He has solicited egg donations at MIT multiple times, since as early as 2009.
Naylor has had two children with eggs donated from members of the MIT community, according to comments he made to The Tech. He estimates he interviewed over 50 candidates in the process.
The children are being raised by two different mothers, and were conceived as part of two relationships Naylor was formerly in. Both women were in their 40s. Naylor, now with a new woman, says he ran the ad again hoping for another child.
While not all details were verifiable at the time of publication, Naylors comments about his profession, alma mater, and place of residence were supported by independent research done by The Tech this week.
Members of the MIT community were concerned by the message and wording of the ad. I cannot help to suspect he is merely looking to get in contact with young, smart, but financially vulnerable Asian female students with some dodgy intent, one alum wrote on a mailing list.
The ad described the ideal candidate as a 21 year old Chinese MIT student, top in her class, several awards in high school and university. (According to Naylor, all three girlfriends he has run the ads with have been Chinese.)
Robin Scheffler, an MIT professor in the Science, Technology, and Society Program who focuses on the history of biomedical sciences, said that the ad relies on an assumption that intelligence and success are strongly linked to genetics. Such an assumption, Scheffler wrote over email, is scientifically and socially misguided as well as deeply problematic in a historical sense.
There are considerable risks associated with donating eggs, none of which made it into the ad. These include premenstrual syndrome and ovarian hyperstimulation syndrome. According to the New York Department of Health, some studies have shown that the required fertility drugs may also increase the risk of developing ovarian cancer.
Naylor acknowledged these health hazards, but claimed that he always offers to pay the women for an independent consultation with a doctor of their choice to review the medical procedure beforehand. He maintained that the women are well-informed and able to decide for themselves.
Scheffler, however, cited the possible danger that women in dire financial condition would feel they had no choice but to undertake a risky procedure with potential long-term medical risks to donate their eggs. He continued: As an ethical matter this is not the kind of choice that a just society should ask women or anyone to make.
This unfair burden is especially relevant to the The Techs decision to run the ad, Scheffler said, given that publishing advertisements for egg donors draws college newspapers into these broader ethical debates.
The chairman of The Tech, Olivia Brode-Roger 17, approved the ad because it did not fall under any of the three categories that she looks for before rejecting an ad: emulation of content, direct calls to harm, or an obvious scam.
The decision is one that other members of the managing board were not fully behind. Prior to this incident, the chairman had full authority to accept or reject any advertisement brought to her. In response to the egg donor ad, The Techs managing board unanimously decided to expand that authority to apply to all members of the managing board who are not associated with news, opinion, arts, or other content.
As for Naylor, the reason he and his girlfriends have sought egg donors from MIT is that he believes their other options have failed. The women have been infertile, the egg donor clinics have been amazingly skittish, and the reactions from faculty at Caltech where he also used to advertise have kept him away.
The two previously successful donations from MIT led him to re-run the ad here. He anticipated that there [was] going to be a shit storm, but says that he caved in.
To the critics, he wished they could meet the 40-something woman that is desperate for a child and doesnt have one and hear her crying about it, and hear her desperation.
So far, the ad has yielded three responses. Two have been from reporters. Only one was an MIT student with potential interest, but Naylor suspects that the ensuing controversy might have now scared her away.
Originally posted here:
Blunt egg donor ad generates controversy among students, CSAIL – The Tech
- I Used An Egg Donor And I'm PROUD To Admit It - YourTango - April 26th, 2017
- Key factors you need to consider before IVF according to leading Irish experts - Irish Independent - April 26th, 2017
- 'Age, age and age' and other key factors you need to consider ... - Irish Independent - April 25th, 2017
- How faith communities view different fertility treatments - KHOU - April 25th, 2017
- Fertility specialists from Ireland and the US host a free egg donation seminar - Waterford Today - April 23rd, 2017
- Making the match: How women become surrogates - USA Today - USA TODAY - April 23rd, 2017
- How faith communities view different fertility treatments - USA TODAY - April 23rd, 2017
- Breeding out disease - CBS News - April 23rd, 2017
- Cryopreservation Systems Market - Trends and Forecasts by Technavio - Yahoo Finance - April 22nd, 2017
- Extraordinary Conceptions increases level of care for surrogates - Yahoo Finance - April 20th, 2017
- Who were the top donors to Trump's inauguration? - CBS News - April 20th, 2017
- Fighting for children's rights in the high-tech fertility age - Medical Xpress - April 17th, 2017
- Egg donation: give the gift of life this Easter - Chinchilla News - April 16th, 2017
- Numbers travelling for donor egg fertility treatment up by 50% | Irish ... - Irish Examiner - April 15th, 2017
- Children's rights in high-tech fertility age - ScienceBlog.com - ScienceBlog.com (blog) - April 15th, 2017
- Proposed in vitro law underway in Hawaii - Washington Blade - April 14th, 2017
- Cryos International USA Proactively Prevents the Spread of Zika in Sperm Donations - Benzinga - April 13th, 2017
- Egg Donor Moms Come Out of the Closet - GlobeNewswire - GlobeNewswire (press release) - April 12th, 2017
- Renewed calls for SA Government to implement sperm, egg donor register - ABC Online - April 12th, 2017
- Ways To Make Money In A Pinch - witf.org - April 12th, 2017
- Next on LGBT agenda: Get insurers to pay for fertility treatment - Columbus Alive - April 11th, 2017
- FILM REVIEW: Indie Film "OVUM" Takes a Look at the World of Egg Donors - Splash Report (press release) (blog) - April 11th, 2017
- Egg Donor Moms Come Out of the Closet - GlobeNewswire (press release) - April 10th, 2017
- LGBT couples seek equal access to fertility treatment - Asheville Citizen-Times - April 10th, 2017
- Hawaii LGBT couples seek equal access to fertility treatment - WTOP - April 10th, 2017
- Fertility experts from Ireland and the US host a free egg donation seminar in Cork - TheCork.ie - April 10th, 2017
- 'Nikki' donor: Women in Delhi-NCR donate eggs to couples for money - India Today - April 9th, 2017
- Egg Donors - Northeast Assisted Fertility Group - April 6th, 2017
- Photo: Armenian Students' Association holds culture festival in Bruin Plaza - Daily Bruin - April 5th, 2017
- Chinese Girls are Selling Their Eggs for Up to $41,000 on the Black ... - NextShark - April 1st, 2017
- Japan seen lagging in creating egg donation system for infertile women - The Japan Times - March 26th, 2017
- British Scientists Receive Permission to Develop Baby From Three People - legal Insurrection (blog) - March 26th, 2017
- How Being A Surrogate Showed This Mom How Strong Women Can Be - Huffington Post - March 24th, 2017
- We're bringing Sexy Mac: an eggcellent endeavour - Macalester College The Mac Weekly - March 24th, 2017
- UK grants 1st license to make babies using DNA from 3 people ... - KRON4.com - March 23rd, 2017
- UK grants 1st license to make babies using DNA from 3 people - NH1 News - March 22nd, 2017
- In Japan first, woman gives birth using egg from anonymous donor ... - The Japan Times - March 22nd, 2017
- Looking for a Sperm or Egg Donor? Now There's an App for That - Sputnik International - March 21st, 2017
- New Mom Shannon M. Clark on What It's Like to Get Pregnant Using ... - Glamour - March 20th, 2017
- UK grants 1st license to make babies using DNA from 3 people ... - WDEF News 12 - March 19th, 2017
- What to Think About When Considering Donating Your Eggs - Rewire - March 17th, 2017
- Just-A-Baby App Promises To Be Tinder For Sperm Donors - AskMen - March 17th, 2017
- UK grants 1st license to make babies using DNA from 3 people - San Angelo Standard Times - March 17th, 2017
- The Powerful Lesson One Woman Learned From Being a Surrogate - Redbookmag.com (blog) - March 17th, 2017
- There's now an app that can match you with the sperm donor of your dreams - The Sun - March 15th, 2017
- 'We were all a family': Preemie mom's poem to thank hospital staff - fox6now.com - March 14th, 2017
- Half Siblings from Sperm and Egg Donation - Huffington Post - March 14th, 2017
- Family Source Consultants, one of North America's leading ... - MilTech - March 14th, 2017
- Global Donor Egg IVFs Market 2017 Pacific Fertility Egg Bank, World Egg Bank - DailyHover - March 13th, 2017
- Couple who survived stage four cancer appeal for egg donors to start next stage of their life - Liverpool Echo - March 12th, 2017
- New law repeals anonymity of sperm and egg donors - Neos Kosmos - March 10th, 2017
- Sperm & Egg Donation: Telling is the First Step - Huffington Post - March 10th, 2017
- Medical tourism to Russia is booming | Russia Beyond The Headlines - Russia Beyond the Headlines - March 10th, 2017
- Challenges of Starting a Family After 40 - Healthline - March 10th, 2017
- Surrogacy Bill will ban singles from being parents - The Hindu - March 9th, 2017
- Diblings, Duncles, And Triplings Oh My! - Above the Law - March 9th, 2017
- Don't put all your eggs in one basket, for Herms sake | Free ... - Free Malaysia Today - March 8th, 2017
- Donor anonymity comes to an end in Victoria, Australia - BioNews - March 8th, 2017
- Donate an Egg, Become Infertile - Huffington Post - March 5th, 2017
- You'll never guess which body part of Malaysian women is being sold now - CILISOS.MY - March 5th, 2017
- North and north-east facing sperm crisis - Press and Journal - March 5th, 2017
- Known Egg Donors - Lending a helping hand to couples in ... - March 2nd, 2017
- Victoria's changes to laws on tracing sperm and egg donors a sensible evolution - The Age - March 2nd, 2017
- Victoria's world-first change to share sperm or egg donors' names ... - The Conversation AU - March 1st, 2017
- How This Company Found a Better Way to Help Women Get Pregnant - Inc.com - March 1st, 2017
- Katherine one step closer to finding her father after donor law changes - The Age - March 1st, 2017
- GenePeeks Announces Additional Partnerships with The Donor Solution and 3 Sisters Surrogacy - Yahoo Finance - February 28th, 2017
- Regulating the donor-conception industry in the US - BioNews - February 28th, 2017
- Women selling ovum for RM3,000-RM8,000, says report | Free ... - Free Malaysia Today - February 28th, 2017
- Stories making the Swiss Sunday papers | News | Expatica ... - Expatica Switzerland - February 27th, 2017
- Egg/sperm donation industry is a religious liberty issue - CatholicPhilly.com - February 24th, 2017
- Become an Egg Donor | Shady Grove Fertility - February 23rd, 2017
- Why Older Mothers Should Be Open About Fertility Issues - TIME - February 23rd, 2017
- Donate an Egg, Become Infertile - Healthline - February 23rd, 2017
- Preimplantation Genetic Testing Market Value Share, Analysis and Segments 2017-2027 - Satellite PR News (press release) - February 22nd, 2017
- How to make a 'three-parent' baby - Science News for Students (blog) - February 21st, 2017
- Cheers & Jeers - Quad-Cities Online - February 18th, 2017
- Egg-free surrogate chickens produced in bid to save rare breeds - Science Daily - February 18th, 2017
- Egg-free surrogate chickens produced in bid to save rare breeds - Phys.Org - February 17th, 2017
- Hello, again, Dolly - The Economist - February 16th, 2017